| Batter Rank | Player | Selected By |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Mike Trout LAA – OF | Homeslice |
| 2 | Mookie Betts Bos – OF | Dirty3rdRider |
| 3 | Nolan Arenado Col – 3B | caliwodie |
| 4 | J.D. Martinez Bos – OF | BigRed |
| 5 | Trea Turner Was – SS | Dirty3rdRider |
| 6 | José Ramírez Cle – 2B,3B | Mista Mac |
| 7 | Ronald Acuña Jr. Atl – OF | BadBoy |
| 8 | Christian Yelich Mil – OF | HighChief |
| 9 | Jose Altuve Hou – 2B | Blayze |
| 10 | Alex Bregman Hou – 3B,SS | tburnett |
| 11 | Freddie Freeman Atl – 1B | caliwodie |
| 12 | Bryce Harper Phi – OF | BruteMac |
| 13 | Trevor Story Col – SS | BigRed |
| 14 | Javier Báez ChC – 2B,3B,SS | sexiestmanalive |
| 15 | Giancarlo Stanton NYY – OF | Homeslice |
| 16 | Aaron Judge NYY – OF | Dirty3rdRider |
| 17 | Paul Goldschmidt StL – 1B | Blayze |
| 18 | Francisco Lindor Cle – SS | Blayze |
| 19 | Manny Machado SD – 3B,SS | Homeslice |
| 20 | Charlie Blackmon Col – OF | sexiestmanalive |
| 21 | Andrew Benintendi Bos – OF | tburnett |
| 22 | Kris Bryant ChC – 3B,OF | Blayze |
| 23 | Juan Soto Was – OF | BigRed |
| 24 | Starling Marte Pit – OF | BadBoy |
| 25 | Anthony Rizzo ChC – 1B | BadBoy |
| 26 | Whit Merrifield KC – 1B,2B,OF | caliwodie |
| 27 | Carlos Correa Hou – SS | sexiestmanalive |
| 28 | Rhys Hoskins Phi – 1B,OF | ILLusionist |
| 29 | Anthony Rendon Was – 3B | HighChief |
| 30 | Vladimir Guerrero Jr. Tor – 3B | Homeslice |
| 31 | Xander Bogaerts Bos – SS | HighChief |
| 32 | Khris Davis Oak – OF | ILLusionist |
| 33 | George Springer Hou – OF | sexiestmanalive |
| 34 | Cody Bellinger LAD – 1B,OF | Homeslice |
| 35 | Lorenzo Cain Mil – OF | BigRed |
| 36 | Joey Votto Cin – 1B | tburnett |
| 37 | José Abreu CWS – 1B | HighChief |
| 38 | Gleyber Torres NYY – 2B,SS | BigRed |
| 39 | Daniel Murphy Col – 1B,2B | Homeslice |
| 40 | Eugenio Suárez Cin – 3B | ILLusionist |
| 41 | Ozzie Albies Atl – 2B | Dirty3rdRider |
| 42 | Marcell Ozuna StL – OF | sexiestmanalive |
| 43 | Corey Seager LAD – SS | Mista Mac |
| 44 | Adalberto Mondesi KC – 2B,SS | Blayze |
| 45 | Jean Segura Phi – SS | BruteMac |
| 46 | Gary Sánchez NYY – C | BigRed |
| 47 | Justin Upton LAA – OF | BruteMac |
| 48 | Nelson Cruz Min – Util | Mista Mac |
| 49 | Eddie Rosario Min – OF | HighChief |
| 50 | J.T. Realmuto Phi – C,1B | Mista Mac |
| 51 | Tommy Pham TB – OF | Mista Mac |
| 52 | Yasiel Puig Cin – OF | ILLusionist |
| 53 | Mitch Haniger Sea – OF | ILLusionist |
| 54 | Jesús Aguilar Mil – 1B | BruteMac |
| 55 | A.J. Pollock LAD – OF | tburnett |
| 56 | Matt Carpenter StL – 1B,2B,3B | Dirty3rdRider |
| 57 | Jonathan Villar Bal – 2B,SS | BigRed |
| 58 | Nicholas Castellanos Det – OF | Dirty3rdRider |
| 59 | Justin Turner LAD – 3B | ILLusionist |
| 60 | Miguel Andújar NYY – 3B | Dirty3rdRider |
| 61 | Josh Donaldson Atl – 3B | BruteMac |
| 62 | Scooter Gennett Cin – 2B | sexiestmanalive |
| 63 | David Dahl Col – OF | tburnett |
| 64 | Matt Olson Oak – 1B | BadBoy |
| 65 | Matt Chapman Oak – 3B | BadBoy |
| 66 | Michael Conforto NYM – OF | HighChief |
| 67 | Edwin Encarnacion Sea – 1B | Mista Mac |
| 68 | Wil Myers SD – 3B,OF | caliwodie |
| 69 | Dee Gordon Sea – 2B,SS,OF | BadBoy |
| 70 | Rougned Odor Tex – 2B | HighChief |
| 71 | Aaron Hicks NYY – OF | caliwodie |
| 72 | Joey Gallo Tex – 1B,OF | Blayze |
| 73 | Michael Brantley Hou – OF | tburnett |
| 74 | Andrew McCutchen Phi – OF | BigRed |
| 75 | Rafael Devers Bos – 3B | ILLusionist |
| 76 | Robinson Canó NYM – 1B,2B | Homeslice |
| 77 | David Peralta Ari – OF | BadBoy |
| 78 | Ender Inciarte Atl – OF | BruteMac |
| 79 | Victor Robles Was – OF | Blayze |
| 80 | Eloy Jiménez CWS – OF | HighChief |
| 81 | Mallex Smith Sea – OF | Blayze |
| 82 | Brian Dozier Was – 2B | BruteMac |
| 83 | Max Muncy LAD – 1B,2B,3B | Mista Mac |
| 84 | Tim Anderson CWS – SS | BruteMac |
| 85 | Elvis Andrus Tex – SS | BadBoy |
| 86 | Nomar Mazara Tex – OF | Mista Mac |
| 87 | Mike Moustakas Mil – 3B | BruteMac |
| 88 | Ian Desmond Col – 1B,OF | Blayze |
| 89 | José Peraza Cin – SS | HighChief |
| 90 | César Hernández Phi – 2B | BruteMac |
| 91 | Buster Posey SF – C,1B | Homeslice |
| 92 | Miguel Cabrera Det – 1B | sexiestmanalive |
| 93 | Kyle Schwarber ChC – OF | Blayze |
| 94 | Stephen Piscotty Oak – OF | sexiestmanalive |
| 95 | Willson Contreras ChC – C | tburnett |
| 96 | Yadier Molina StL – C | BruteMac |
| 97 | Billy Hamilton KC – OF | Mista Mac |
| 98 | Eric Hosmer SD – 1B | HighChief |
| 99 | Travis Shaw Mil – 1B,2B,3B | BigRed |
| 100 | Ryan Braun Mil – 1B,OF | caliwodie |
| 101 | Yasmani Grandal Mil – C | tburnett |
| 102 | Yoán Moncada CWS – 2B | tburnett |
| 103 | Jonathan Schoop Min – 2B,SS | ILLusionist |
| 104 | Carlos Santana Cle – 1B,3B | HighChief |
| 105 | Justin Smoak Tor – 1B | Dirty3rdRider |
| 106 | Adam Eaton Was – OF | caliwodie |
| 107 | Harrison Bader StL – OF | Dirty3rdRider |
| 108 | Jurickson Profar Oak – 1B,2B,3B,SS | Mista Mac |
| 109 | Corey Dickerson Pit – OF | |
| 110 | Brandon Nimmo NYM – OF | tburnett |
| 111 | Odúbel Herrera Phi – OF | Dirty3rdRider |
| 112 | Miguel Sanó Min – 1B,3B | sexiestmanalive |
| 113 | Byron Buxton Min – OF | ILLusionist |
| 114 | Gregory Polanco Pit – OF | sexiestmanalive |
| 115 | Paul DeJong StL – SS | caliwodie |
| 116 | Austin Meadows TB – OF | Blayze |
| 117 | Marcus Semien Oak – SS | |
| 118 | Shin-soo Choo Tex – OF | caliwodie |
| 119 | Jake Bauers Cle – 1B,OF | Mista Mac |
| 120 | DJ LeMahieu NYY – 2B | tburnett |
| 121 | Josh Bell Pit – 1B | sexiestmanalive |
| 122 | Amed Rosario NYM – SS | tburnett |
| 123 | Wilson Ramos NYM – C | Blayze |
| 124 | Luke Voit NYY – 1B | |
| 125 | Jesse Winker Cin – OF | Blayze |
| 126 | Jackie Bradley Jr. Bos – OF | BruteMac |
| 127 | Kyle Seager Sea – 3B | |
| 128 | Eduardo Escobar Ari – 3B,SS | |
| 129 | Andrelton Simmons LAA – SS | Dirty3rdRider |
| 130 | Franmil Reyes SD – OF | BigRed |
| 131 | Chris Taylor LAD – 2B,SS,OF | |
| 132 | Adam Jones Bal – OF | |
| 133 | Manuel Margot SD – OF | BadBoy |
| 134 | Ramón Laureano Oak – OF | |
| 135 | José Martínez StL – 1B,OF | Mista Mac |
| 136 | Lourdes Gurriel Jr. Tor – 2B,SS | caliwodie |
| 137 | Ian Happ ChC – 3B,OF | |
| 138 | Nick Senzel Cin – 3B | Homeslice |
| 139 | Tyler White Hou – 1B | |
| 140 | Hunter Renfroe SD – OF | sexiestmanalive |
| 141 | Domingo Santana Sea – OF | BigRed |
| 142 | Max Kepler Min – OF | |
| 143 | Evan Longoria SF – 3B | |
| 144 | Yuli Gurriel Hou – 1B,2B,3B | sexiestmanalive |
| 145 | Trey Mancini Bal – 1B,OF | |
| 146 | Yonder Alonso CWS – 1B | |
| 147 | Yan Gomes Was – C | caliwodie |
| 148 | Jorge Polanco Min – SS | |
| 149 | Asdrúbal Cabrera Tex – 2B,3B,SS | ILLusionist |
| 150 | Nick Markakis Atl – OF | |
| 151 | Randal Grichuk Tor – OF | |
| 152 | C.J. Cron Min – 1B | |
| 153 | Jed Lowrie NYM – 2B,3B | |
| 154 | Ryan Zimmerman Was – 1B | |
| 155 | Willy Adames TB – 2B,SS | Homeslice |
| 156 | Yoenis Céspedes NYM – OF | tburnett |
| 157 | Jake Lamb Ari – 3B | |
| 158 | Brandon Belt SF – 1B,OF | |
| 159 | Francisco Cervelli Pit – C | |
| 160 | Kevin Kiermaier TB – OF | |
| 161 | Garrett Hampson Col – 2B,SS | HighChief |
| 162 | Ketel Marte Ari – 2B,SS | Dirty3rdRider |
| 163 | Didi Gregorius NYY – SS | ILLusionist |
| 164 | Maikel Franco Phi – 3B | Dirty3rdRider |
| 165 | Steven Souza Jr. Ari – OF | |
| 166 | Matt Kemp Cin – OF | |
| 167 | Kevin Pillar Tor – OF | |
| 168 | Cedric Mullins Bal – OF | |
| 169 | Avisaíl García TB – OF | |
| 170 | Brett Gardner NYY – OF | |
| 171 | Wilmer Flores Ari – 1B,2B,3B | |
| 172 | Starlin Castro Mia – 2B | |
| 173 | Zack Cozart LAA – 2B,3B,SS | |
| 174 | Mike Zunino TB – C | BadBoy |
| 175 | Jung Ho Kang Pit – 3B | |
| 176 | Ian Kinsler SD – 2B | |
| 177 | Welington Castillo CWS – C | HighChief |
| 178 | Luis Urías SD – 2B | |
| 179 | Kyle Tucker Hou – OF | Dirty3rdRider |
| 180 | Jason Kipnis Cle – 2B,OF | |
| 181 | Marwin González Min – 1B,2B,SS,OF | caliwodie |
| 182 | Danny Jansen Tor – C | Dirty3rdRider |
| 183 | Tucker Barnhart Cin – C,1B | |
| 184 | Peter Alonso NYM – 1B | tburnett |
| 185 | Troy Tulowitzki NYY – SS | |
| 186 | Justin Bour LAA – 1B | |
| 187 | Brian Anderson Mia – 3B,OF | |
| 188 | Jorge Soler KC – OF | |
| 189 | Kendrys Morales Tor – 1B | |
| 190 | Joey Wendle TB – 2B,3B,SS,OF | Blayze |
| 191 | Francisco Mejía SD – C | sexiestmanalive |
| 192 | Carlos González Col – OF | |
| 193 | Ben Zobrist ChC – 2B,OF | caliwodie |
| 194 | Johan Camargo Atl – 3B,SS | |
| 195 | Josh Reddick Hou – OF | |
| 196 | Shohei Ohtani (Batter) LAA – Util | Mista Mac |
| 197 | Denard Span Sea – OF | |
| 198 | Gerardo Parra SF – OF | |
| 199 | Ryon Healy Sea – 1B | |
| 200 | Freddy Galvis Tor – 2B,SS |
Bo Bichette Tor – SS – sexiestmanalive
Carson Kelly Ari – C – sexiestmanalive
Adam Haseley Phi – OF – Blayze
Jesus Sanchez TB – OF – Blayze
Alex Verdugo LAD – OF – caliwodie
Fernando Tatis Jr. SD – SS – caliwodie
Yusniel Diaz BAL – OF – caliwodie
Keibert Ruiz LAD – C – BigRed
Jo Adell LAA – OF – BigRed
Alex Kirilloff Min – OF – BigRed
Estevan Florial NYY – OF – BigRed
Willie Calhoun TEX – OF – Homeslice
Nick Gordon MIN – SS – Mista Mac
Yordan Alvarez HOU – OF – BruteMac
Austin Riley ATL – 3B – Mista Mac
Kyle Lewis SEA – OF – Dirty3rdRider
Keston Hiura MIL – 2B – BadBoy
Brendan Rodgers COL – SS – BadBoy
Taylor Trammel CIN – OF – HighChief
Leody Taveras TEX – OF – BruteMac
Royce Lewis MIN – SS – ILLusionist
Jorge Mateo OAK – SS – ILLusionist
Brendan McKay TB – 1B – tburnett
Luis Urias SD – SS – tburnett
Joey Bart SF – C – Blayze
Jarred Kelenic SEA – OF – Mista Mac
Carter Keiboom WAS – SS – BadBoy
Wander Franco TB – SS – BruteMac
Victor Victor Mesa MIA – OF – BadBoy
Nick Madrigal CWS – 2B – BruteMac
Sean Murphy OAK – C – BadBoy
Michael Chavis BOS – 3B – BadBoy
Willians Astudillo MIN – C, 3B – ILLusionist
