| Pitcher Rank | Player | Selected By |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Max Scherzer Was – SP | Mista Mac |
| 2 | Jacob deGrom NYM – SP | HighChief |
| 3 | Chris Sale Bos – SP | tburnett |
| 4 | Justin Verlander Hou – SP | Mista Mac |
| 5 | Corey Kluber Cle – SP | BruteMac |
| 6 | Gerrit Cole Hou – SP | Blayze |
| 7 | Blake Snell TB – SP | Homeslice |
| 8 | Luis Severino NYY – SP | BigRed |
| 9 | Aaron Nola Phi – SP | HighChief |
| 10 | Carlos Carrasco Cle – SP | ILLusionist |
| 11 | Walker Buehler LAD – SP | Blayze |
| 12 | Noah Syndergaard NYM – SP | Dirty3rdRider |
| 13 | Trevor Bauer Cle – SP | HighChief |
| 14 | Zack Greinke Ari – SP | BigRed |
| 15 | Jack Flaherty StL – SP | BigRed |
| 16 | James Paxton NYY – SP | Homeslice |
| 17 | José Berríos Min – SP | BadBoy |
| 18 | Edwin Díaz NYM – RP | BruteMac |
| 19 | Patrick Corbin Was – SP | caliwodie |
| 20 | Stephen Strasburg Was – SP | caliwodie |
| 21 | Jameson Taillon Pit – SP | Homeslice |
| 22 | Blake Treinen Oak – RP | ILLusionist |
| 23 | Kenley Jansen LAD – RP | ILLusionist |
| 24 | Aroldis Chapman NYY – RP | caliwodie |
| 25 | Mike Clevinger Cle – SP | BigRed |
| 26 | Zack Wheeler NYM – SP | sexiestmanalive |
| 27 | David Price Bos – SP | ILLusionist |
| 28 | Felipe Vázquez Pit – RP | BadBoy |
| 29 | Craig Kimbrel Bos – RP | Mista Mac |
| 30 | Roberto Osuna Hou – RP | BigRed |
| 31 | Masahiro Tanaka NYY – SP | sexiestmanalive |
| 32 | Miles Mikolas StL – SP | BigRed |
| 33 | Brad Hand Cle – RP | Mista Mac |
| 34 | Madison Bumgarner SF – SP | BruteMac |
| 35 | German Márquez Col – SP | BigRed |
| 36 | Charlie Morton TB – SP | BruteMac |
| 37 | Robbie Ray Ari – SP | Dirty3rdRider |
| 38 | Sean Doolittle Was – RP | caliwodie |
| 39 | Kirby Yates SD – RP | HighChief |
| 40 | Clayton Kershaw LAD – SP | tburnett |
| 41 | Wade Davis Col – RP | HighChief |
| 42 | Chris Archer Pit – SP | Blayze |
| 43 | Mike Foltynewicz Atl – SP | BruteMac |
| 44 | Kyle Hendricks ChC – SP | Mista Mac |
| 45 | Josh Hader Mil – RP | HighChief |
| 46 | Luis Castillo Cin – SP | Dirty3rdRider |
| 47 | Ken Giles Tor – RP | Dirty3rdRider |
| 48 | Dallas Keuchel Hou – SP | caliwodie |
| 49 | José Leclerc Tex – RP | BigRed |
| 50 | Cole Hamels ChC – SP | Dirty3rdRider |
| 51 | Eduardo Rodriguez Bos – SP | Homeslice |
| 52 | Nick Pivetta Phi – SP | Mista Mac |
| 53 | Yu Darvish ChC – SP | BigRed |
| 54 | Raisel Iglesias Cin – RP | HighChief |
| 55 | J.A. Happ NYY – SP | BruteMac |
| 56 | Andrew Heaney LAA – SP | ILLusionist |
| 57 | Rich Hill LAD – SP | HighChief |
| 58 | Tyler Glasnow TB – SP,RP | ILLusionist |
| 59 | Shane Bieber Cle – SP | Homeslice |
| 60 | David Robertson Phi – RP | Blayze |
| 61 | Rick Porcello Bos – SP | BruteMac |
| 62 | José Quintana ChC – SP | Blayze |
| 63 | Corey Knebel Mil – RP | Mista Mac |
| 64 | Nathan Eovaldi Bos – SP | sexiestmanalive |
| 65 | Andrew Miller StL – RP | Homeslice |
| 66 | Kenta Maeda LAD – SP,RP | Homeslice |
| 67 | Cody Allen LAA – RP | BruteMac |
| 68 | Archie Bradley Ari – RP | Blayze |
| 69 | Alex Reyes StL – SP | sexiestmanalive |
| 70 | Ross Stripling LAD – SP,RP | Homeslice |
| 71 | Hyun-Jin Ryu LAD – SP | caliwodie |
| 72 | Jake Arrieta Phi – SP | Dirty3rdRider |
| 73 | Kevin Gausman Atl – SP | HighChief |
| 74 | Dellin Betances NYY – RP | sexiestmanalive |
| 75 | Jon Lester ChC – SP | BruteMac |
| 76 | Joey Lucchesi SD – SP | caliwodie |
| 77 | Jon Gray Col – SP | BigRed |
| 78 | Kyle Freeland Col – SP | tburnett |
| 79 | Yusei Kikuchi Sea – SP | Mista Mac |
| 80 | Alex Colomé CWS – RP | tburnett |
| 81 | Arodys Vizcaíno Atl – RP | BadBoy |
| 82 | Will Smith SF – RP | HighChief |
| 83 | Jordan Hicks StL – RP | caliwodie |
| 84 | A.J. Minter Atl – RP | Dirty3rdRider |
| 85 | Sean Newcomb Atl – SP | Homeslice |
| 86 | Mychal Givens Bal – RP | Homeslice |
| 87 | Alex Wood Cin – SP,RP | sexiestmanalive |
| 88 | Zack Godley Ari – SP | Dirty3rdRider |
| 89 | Pedro Strop ChC – RP | sexiestmanalive |
| 90 | Josh James Hou – SP | Dirty3rdRider |
| 91 | Luke Weaver Ari – SP,RP | tburnett |
| 92 | Carlos Rodón CWS – SP | Blayze |
| 93 | Seranthony Domínguez Phi – RP | caliwodie |
| 94 | José Alvarado TB – RP | Homeslice |
| 95 | Collin McHugh Hou – RP | Blayze |
| 96 | Tyler Skaggs LAA – SP | Mista Mac |
| 97 | Kelvin Herrera CWS – RP | BruteMac |
| 98 | Carlos Martínez StL – SP,RP | BadBoy |
| 99 | Kyle Gibson Min – SP | |
| 100 | Jeurys Familia NYM – RP | tburnett |
| 101 | Chase Anderson Mil – SP | sexiestmanalive |
| 102 | Brandon Morrow ChC – RP | Homeslice |
| 103 | Steven Matz NYM – SP | BadBoy |
| 104 | Michael Fulmer Det – SP | BadBoy |
| 105 | Adam Ottavino NYY – RP | sexiestmanalive |
| 106 | Jesus Luzardo Oak – SP | Homeslice |
| 107 | Trevor May Min – RP | Homeslice |
| 108 | Drew Steckenrider Mia – RP | |
| 109 | Joe Jiménez Det – RP | BadBoy |
| 110 | Matt Barnes Bos – RP | Mista Mac |
| 111 | Julio Teheran Atl – SP | HighChief |
| 112 | Joe Musgrove Pit – SP | Blayze |
| 113 | Johnny Cueto SF – SP | |
| 114 | Zack Britton NYY – RP | Dirty3rdRider |
| 115 | Freddy Peralta Mil – SP | |
| 116 | Marcus Stroman Tor – SP | sexiestmanalive |
| 117 | Jeremy Jeffress Mil – RP | |
| 118 | Jimmy Nelson Mil – SP | Blayze |
| 119 | Shane Greene Det – RP | Homeslice |
| 120 | Blake Parker Min – RP | |
| 121 | Mike Soroka Atl – SP | sexiestmanalive |
| 122 | Shohei Ohtani (Pitcher) LAA – SP | BadBoy |
| 123 | Chad Green NYY – RP | HighChief |
| 124 | Jhoulys Chacín Mil – SP | |
| 125 | Yusmeiro Petit Oak – RP |
Julio Urías LAD – RP – sexiestmanalive
Kyle Wright ATL – RP – Blayze
MacKenzie Gore SD – SP – Blayze
Hunter Greene Cin – SP – caliwodie
Adrian Morejon SD – SP – caliwodie
Jon Duplantier Ari – SP – caliwodie
Forrest Whitley Hou – SP – BigRed
Lance McCullers Jr. HOU – SP – Homeslice
Dylan Cease CWS – SP – Homeslice
Michel Baez SD – SP – Mista Mac
Stephen Gonsalves MIN – SP – Mista Pac
J.B. Bukauskas Hou – SP – Dirty3rdRider
Chance Adams NYY – P – Dirty3rdRider
Luiz Gohara ATL – RP – Dirty3rdRider
Ian Anderson ATL – SP – BadBoy
Sixto Sanchez PHI – SP – BadBoy
Michael Kopech CWS – SP – BadBoy
AJ Puk OAK – SP – HighChief
Brent Honeywell TB – SP – HighChief
Justus Sheffield SEA – SP – HighChief
Jose Urena MIA – SP – BruteMac
Franklin Perez DET – SP – BruteMac
Mitch Keller PIT – SP – ILLusionist
Chris Paddack SD – SP – tburnett
Triston McKenzie CLE – SP – tburnett
Brad Boxberger MIN – RP – tburnett
Casey Mize DET – SP – BadBoy
Yusei Kikuchi SEA – SP – caliwodie
Marco Gonzales SEA – SP – Mista Mac
Touki Toussiant ATL – SP – tburnett
Zach Eflin PHI – SP – ILLusionist
Matt Strahm SD – SP, RP – BigRed
Michael Pineda MIN – SP – ILLusionist
Sonny Gray CIN – SP – tburnett
Reynaldo Lopez CWS – SP – Mista Mac
Vince Velasquez PHI – SP – ILLusionist
Brad Peacock HOU – RP – BigRed
Sergio Romo TB – RP – Blayze
Jonathan Loaisiga NYY – SP, RP – BadBoy
